EPIC – “The Second Circuit Court of Appeals ruled today that the NSA’s telephone record collection program exceeds legal authority. The government claimed that it could collect all records under the Section 215 “relevance” standard. But the court rejected that argument and held that “such an expansive concept of ‘relevance’ is unprecedented and unwarranted.” The conclusion mirrors the argument EPIC, and a coalition of technical expert, legal scholars, and former members of the Church Committee made in Petition to the Supreme Court in 2013. EPIC explained in its petition, “It is simply not possible that every phone record in the possession of a telecommunications firm could be relevant to an authorized investigation.” The Second Circuit found that Section 215 does not “authorize anything approaching the breadth of the sweeping surveillance at issue here.”

• See also The Atlantic – Does the PATRIOT Act Allow Bulk Surveillance? Debate over NSA collection of phone metadata has often focused on whether the law is constitutional—but a federal appeals court says it’s not even legal.