Accurate, Focused Research on Law, Technology and Knowledge Discovery Since 2002

How the Malleus maleficarum fueled the witch trial craze

Ars Technica: “Between 1400 and 1775, a significant upsurge of witch trials swept across early-modern Europe, resulting in the execution of an estimated 40,000–60,000 accused witches. Historians and social scientists have long studied this period in hopes of learning more about how large-scale social changes occur. Some have pointed to the invention of the printing press and the publication of witch-hunting manuals—most notably the highly influential Malleus maleficarum—as a major factor, making it easier for the witch-hunting hysteria to spread across the continent. The abrupt emergence of the craze and its rapid spread, resulting in a pronounced shift in social behaviors—namely, the often brutal persecution of suspected witches—is consistent with a theory of social change dubbed “ideational diffusion,” according to a new paper published in the journal Theory and Society. There is the introduction of new ideas, reinforced by social networks, that eventually take root and lead to widespread behavioral changes in a society…For cases like the spread of witch trials, “It’s not just that people are coming into contact with a new idea, but that there has to be something cognitively that is happening,” said Doten-Snitker. “People have to grapple with the ideas and undergo some kind of idea adoption. We talk about this as reinterpreting the social world. They have to rethink what’s happening around them in ways that make them think that not only are these attractive new ideas, but also those new ideas prescribe different types of behavior. You have to act differently because of what you’re encountering.” The authors chose to focus on social networks and trade routes for their analysis of the witch trials, building on prior research that prioritized broader economic and environmental factors. Cultural elites were already exchanging ideas through letters, but published books added a new dimension to those exchanges. Researchers studying 21st century social contagion can download massive amounts of online data from social networks. That kind of data is sparse from the medieval era. “We don’t have the same archives of communication,” said Doten-Snitker. “There’s this dual thing happening: the book itself, and people sharing information, arguing back and forth with each other” about new ideas…”

Sorry, comments are closed for this post.